Cockpit Chronicles: Thunderstorms
It's difficult to write this week's Cockpit Chronicles in light of the tragic Learjet crash in Florida. My heartfelt condolences go out to the families and friends of those who lost their lives.
It's far too early to speculate about the cause, but there have been reports of powerful thunderstorms in the area, with tops reaching 45,000 feet.
Airline crews are trained to give thunderstorms a wide berth.
NEVER fly through a thunderstorm!
On our weather radar, generally speaking:
Green indicates light precipitation.
Yellow indicates moderate precipitation.
Red indicates heavy precipitation, potentially associated with powerful thunderstorms.
But thunderstorms aren't the only danger lurking at high altitudes.
There's an aviation phenomenon called coffin corner.
All airplanes have a minimum airspeed below which their wings will stall. Jet aircraft also have a maximum operating speed, beyond which high-speed aerodynamic effects can become dangerous. One such phenomenon is called Mach tuck, where compressibility effects can cause the airplane's nose to pitch downward.
As a jet climbs higher, the margin between its low-speed stall boundary and its high-speed Mach boundary narrows. Eventually, those boundaries converge, establishing the airplane's aerodynamic ceiling.
It's called coffin corner for a reason.
When crossing the oceans, we take off heavy, carrying enormous quantities of fuel. We climb as high as our weight and performance will safely allow, then execute step climbs as we burn fuel and become lighter.
Jets are generally more efficient at higher altitudes, so climbing saves fuel.
But climb too high, too soon, and you can find yourself in a very uncomfortable situation.
One night, flying to Amsterdam, I returned to the cockpit from my break. We were somewhere over the middle of the Atlantic Ocean. It was pitch black outside.
Summertime thunderstorms were scattered across the ocean, painting yellow returns on our radar displays.
As the Captain prepared to head back to the bunk for his break, he briefed me that he had completed our next scheduled step climb.
After he left, I quickly realized something wasn't right.
He had climbed too early.
Our airspeed margin was only about ±12 knots.
In other words, lose 12 knots and we could stall. Gain 12 knots and we could encounter our high-speed Mach tuck.
Not much room for error!
Then we encountered wave-action turbulence.
The autopilot was trying to maintain altitude, pitching the nose up and down while the autothrottles commanded the engines to advance and retard thrust.
Our airspeed began fluctuating.
Down toward the lower red bar on the airspeed indicator, marking our low-speed limit.
Then back up toward the upper red bar, marking our high-speed limit.
Back and forth.
We were bouncing between the boundaries of coffin corner.
I positioned myself, guarding the flight controls, ready to intervene.
I yelled at the First Officer to contact Air Traffic Control and request a lower altitude, urgently waving my index finger downward.
DOWN! WE NEED TO GO DOWN!
The clearance couldn't come fast enough.
When it finally arrived, I immediately dialed in the lower altitude and selected descent.
As we descended into denser air, our low-speed and high-speed margins began widening.
The airplane was happy again.
And I started breathing again, too.
On another summer night, during a blue-water crossing, our weather radar painted ominous red blotches across the screen.
Thunderstorms.
Big ones.
Out over the ocean, thousands of miles from home, your options can become very limited.
We received clearance to deviate left and right to avoid the storm cells.
But weather radar has a nasty limitation.
A powerful thunderstorm can absorb or attenuate the radar signal, obscuring other thunderstorms hiding behind it.
What looks like clear air beyond a storm might not be clear at all.
We were tiptoeing between cells, wondering what might be lurking around the next corner, hoping we wouldn't find ourselves boxed in.
There's nothing quite like threading your way between thunderstorms over a pitch-black ocean to remind you just how small your airplane really is.
Fortunately, flying over land often provides more options.
I remember flying a DC-9 to Atlanta one day with weather seemingly everywhere.
Our radar painted a solid band of red thunderstorms between us and Atlanta.
No gaps.
No safe way to squeeze through.
I looked at our fuel, considered how much we would burn trying to fly around that enormous wall of weather, and made a decision.
We're calling it a day.
We diverted to another airport, landed, refueled, and waited for the weather to pass.
No heroics.
No unnecessary risks.
Just good judgment.
There are a lot of metaphors in these stories.
Sometimes, the guy in charge is wrong.
Sometimes, the greatest danger is what you can't see.
And sometimes, the smartest decision is to change course, land, and wait for the storm to pass.
Blue Skies,
Lorenzo




Comments